Fans may not want to believe it, but all signs are pointing towards the break-up of The Moffatts.
A story in the Victoria Times-Colonist quotes Mike Ravenhill, a family friend of The Moffatts, as saying that one of the triplets, Dave, left the group in August.
"Dave just wants to break away for now. He's just burned," Ravenhill told The Times-Colonist. "These guys have been on top of each other since they were two or three years old."
Ravenhill went on to say that Dave is planning to go to university while the rest of his brothers -- Clint, Scott, and Bob Moffatt -- want to continue making music under a new name.
The emotions in messages posted by Moffatts fans in chatrooms, online fan clubs, and on The Moffatts official message boards range from disbelief to anger.
"I refuse to believe anything about the situation of the moffatts," reads a message on the Yahoo Moffatts club posted by moffatt_fan_4_life2000. "Soon enough I will learn the truth, and that is good enough."
"Okay I have a problem with them," says BabyFire on The Moffatts' message board. "Since everyone knows we basically created the moffatts, why would they want to leave us???? So all our money, all our hopes, is gonna be put in the trash just because some guys couldn't hack it, with a boy band image!"
Although no one officially connected to The Moffatts has directly stated that the group is finished, Bruce Allen Talent, which helps to manage the group, did release a statement, quoted by The Times-Colonist:
"At the present time, there are no concert dates on the books for The Moffatts. It has become obvious to the band that there is a push/pull going on as to what direction the band should take musically. A change in direction not unanimously supported usually means a change in personnel. This is very possible, as members are looking at options."
The Canadian music group made up of one set of triplets and an older brother started singing and recording before they were teens. The group enjoyed huge success in Canada with their pop tunes on the album "Chapter 1/A New Beginning". Their popularity took a nose dive however, when they tried a harder sound on "Submodalities", released last year.
There is some speculation among fans that Dave disagreed with his brothers' decision to change The Moffatts' sound.
"Hey ... did anyone ever think that they're stopping because they aren't making any money anymore?," wrote one fan on The Moffatts Yahoo message board. "Submodalities didn't really do that well world wide, so maybe Dave was like 'wait a minute ... we should stick to pop 'cause we're not doing well as rockers!' And then the other guys were probably like "no, we wanna play rock music!" And another thing ... I know for a fact that they didn't cover the costs of the Aug. 23 Molson Amphitheatre concert ... only 3 000 people came. Then the next night they did a free concert ... there's no money being brought in there! Then there was only 1000 people at the London show on the 25th. I really think it has something to do with the money issue ... but that's just my opinion!'
Lending some credibility to fans' speculation about Dave's problems with The Moffatts' music was Ravenhill's comment to The Times-Colonist that Dave may return to the music world as a solo artist, although he'd pursue a softer sound than the one his siblings have been pushing.
Despite Ravenhill's interview and the statement from the group's talent agency, fans are still confused about what exactly is going on with The Moffatts. If there is any doubt remaining in their minds however about the future of the group, perhaps a clue can be found on The Moffatts' official website.
"Dear friends, Over the past 6 years, The Official Moffatts Web Site has provided news, tour information, photos, chat, message boards, song samples and more," reads the message from the site's webmaster. "We were THE first Moffatt site on the net in 1995 and grew and grew and grew. I would like to take the opportunity to thank all the fans, moms, dads, mom and dad fans, Dave Mack, Williams/Bell & Associates, Provident Financial Mgt, Capitol Records, and of course The Moffatts for all of their help and support over the years. The Moffatts were a band that really appreciated the power of a web site and the need to stay in touch with their fans. They embraced the web site from the beginning. I have been informed that The Official Moffatts Web Site is to be taken down on December 1st, 2001. At that time all email @themoffatts.com will not be available, either, unless something drastically changes. Please make other arrangements for email and clean out your boxes."
The dismantling of The Moffatts' official website could be taken as an (obvious) hint that the group is either taking a (long) break or splitting up.
Officials from The Moffatts' record label were not immediately available to comment on the break-up rumours.